AV-test.org yang bekerjasama
dengan AV-Test GmbH (Jerman) selesai mengadakan berbagai test membandingkan
sekitar 28 Anti virus. Semua produk diambil dari versi terbaik yang diupdate
pada tanggal 7 Januari 2008 dan ditest di dalam sistem operasi Windows XP SP2 (English). Hal ini tentu saja merupakan
Informasi dan test yang sangat bermanfaat sebagai referensi untuk memilih Anti
virus. Pengetesan digunakan sample berbagai virus, trojan horses, backdoors,
bots dan worm yang berjumlah lebih dari 1 juta (1.024.381 sample). Pengetesan-pengetesan
itu adalah sebagai berikut :
a)
Signature-based
Detection
No.
|
Nama Anti Virus
|
Terdeteksi
|
Persentase
|
1.
|
Web
Washer (gateway product only)
|
1023742
|
99,9
%
|
2.
|
AVK
2008
|
1022418
|
99,8
%
|
3.
|
AntiVir
|
1020627
|
99,6
%
|
4.
|
Avast!
|
1018204
|
99,4
%
|
5.
|
Trend
Micro
|
1009662
|
98,6
%
|
6.
|
Symantec
|
1006849
|
98,3
%
|
7.
|
AVG
|
1005006
|
98,1
%
|
8.
|
BitDefender
|
1003902
|
98,0
%
|
9.
|
Kaspersky
|
1003470
|
98,0
%
|
10.
|
Ikarus
|
1002894
|
97,9
%
|
11.
|
Sophos
|
1001655
|
97,8
%
|
12.
|
F-Secure
|
999806
|
97,6
%
|
13.
|
Microsoft
|
992880
|
96,9
%
|
14.
|
F-Prot
|
986961
|
96,3
%
|
15.
|
Panda
|
979409
|
95,6
%
|
16.
|
Rising
|
962674
|
94,0
%
|
17.
|
Norman
|
962191
|
93,9
%
|
18.
|
McAfee
|
959919
|
93,7
%
|
19
|
Fortinet
|
957558
|
93,5
%
|
20.
|
Nod32
|
953936
|
93,1
%
|
21.
|
Dr
Web
|
887736
|
86,7
%
|
22.
|
VBA32
|
885313
|
86,4
%
|
23.
|
QuickHeal
|
862919
|
84,2
%
|
24.
|
ClamAV
|
791505
|
77,3
%
|
25.
|
Command
|
729233
|
71,2
%
|
26.
|
VirusBuster
|
693944
|
67,7
%
|
27.
|
K7
Computing
|
571329
|
55,8
%
|
28.
|
eTrust-VET
|
566161
|
55,3
%
|
Tabel 2.2.
Pengetesan signature-based
b)
False-Positives-Test
Very Good
(0 FP)
|
Good
(1 FP)
|
Satisfactory
(2 FP)
|
Poorly
(3 FP)
|
Very Poor
(>3 FP)
|
eTrust-VET
|
AntiVir
|
Avast!
|
ClamAV
|
Fortinet
|
McAfee
|
AVG
|
AVK 2008
|
Icarus
|
|
Microsoft
|
Command
|
BitDefender
|
||
Symantec
|
F-Prot
|
Dr WebK
|
||
F-Secure
|
7 Computing
|
|||
Nod32
|
Kaspersky
|
|||
Norman
|
Panda
|
|||
Sophos
|
QuickHeal
|
|||
Trend Micro
|
Rising
|
|||
VirusBuster
|
VBA32
|
|||
Web Washer
|
Table 2.3. Perngetesan False-Positives
c)
Proactive detection
Very Good
|
Good
|
Satisfactory
|
Poorly
|
Very Poor
|
BitDefender
|
AntiVir
|
Avast!
|
ClamAV
|
|
Fortinet
|
AVK
2008
|
AVG
|
Command
|
|
F-Secure
|
Dr
Web
|
QuickHeal
|
eTrust-VET
|
|
Nod32
|
Ikarus
|
Rising
|
F-Prot
|
|
Panda
|
Kaspersky
|
K7Computing
|
||
Sophos
|
McAfee
|
Microsoft
|
||
WebWasher
|
Norman
|
VirusBuster
|
||
Symantec
|
||||
Trend
Micro
|
||||
VBA32
|
Table
2.4. Pengetesan Proactive detection
d)
Reaction times
Very Good
(<2 hours)
|
Good
(2-4 hours)
|
Satisfactory
(4-6 hours)
|
Poorly
(6-8 hours)
|
Very Poor
(>6 hours)
|
AntiVir
|
Avast!
|
AVG
|
K7 Computing
|
|
AVK 2008
|
BitDefender
|
Command
|
McAfee
|
|
ClamAV
|
Sophos
|
Dr Web
|
eTrust-VET
|
|
Kaspersky
|
Trend Micro
|
F-Prot
|
Microsoft
|
|
WebWasher
|
Fortinet
|
Norman
|
||
F-Secure
|
Panda
|
|||
Ikarus
|
QuickHeal
|
|||
Nod32
|
Rising
|
|||
Symantec
|
||||
VBA32
|
||||
VirusBuster
|
Table
2.5. Pengetesan Reaction times
e)
Rootkit detection
Very Good
(all detection)
|
Good
(1 not detection)
|
Satisfactory
(2 not detection)
|
Poorly
(3 not detection)
|
Very Poor
(>3 not detection)
|
F-Secure
|
AntiVir
|
F-Prot
|
VirusBuster
|
|
Panda
|
Avast!
|
Ikarus
|
AVK
2008
|
|
Symantec
|
AVG
|
Microsoft
|
QuickHeal
|
|
Trend Micro
|
BitDefender
|
Norman
|
ClamAV
|
|
Dr
Web
|
Rising
|
Command
|
||
eTrust-VET
|
VBA32
|
K7
Computing
|
||
Kaspersky
|
VirusBuster
|
|||
McAfee
|
||||
Nod32
|
||||
Sophos
|
Table
2.6. Pengetesan Rootkit detection
Tidak ada komentar:
Posting Komentar